30 April, 2025
Spaghetti with Meat Sauce

Jay’s Spaghetti
This recipe was inspired by the delicious brown sauce served up at Borrie's Supper Club in Black Eagle just north of Great Falls, MT. I have many memories of our grandparents taking us there for lunch when were quite young.
Equipment
- Medium skillet – one that can handle tomato's acidic qualities (NOT cast iron) and scraping with a metal tool
- Large Heavy Skillet – go cast iron if you can. non-stick just isn't good for browning
- Large pot – for the pasta. bigger is better as it allows the noodles to move around and it also keeps the water at a more consistent temp
Ingredients
- 1 lbl ground beef
- 1 lb Italian sausage
- 2 14 oz cans tomato sauce
- 1 14 oz can diced tomato
- 1 10 oz can tomato paste
- fist full of italian spices
- one yellow onion diced
- several cloves garlic minced
- salt & pepper
- chile flakes or powder
- 1/3 cup red wine or beer more on the side as needed for the paste and the chef
- 1 tsp. lemon or lime juice
- 1 tbls. sugar
- 1/2 cup beef broth
- dash worcestershire sauce
Instructions
- Over very low heat, begin browning the tomato paste in a small skillet. Stir and turn frequently. As the paste dries out, add a little red wine, beer, water, worchestershire sauce as needed to keep it moist but still cooking. This takes a long, long time and a ton of patience but is the most important part of this recipe. Take your time, it’s worth it. Your goal ist to keep stirring in the dark, cooked bits that you scrape up from the bottom back into the mixture. Your goal is a brown paste about the color of dark caramel or cinnamon. It could take an hour or two.
- While the paste is browning, using a large, heavy skillet, saute onion until soft and a bit translucent. Remove from pan and set aside.
- Brown ground beef and sausage. Let it char just a little. Break up into tiny bits as you go. Letting it sit after intitial breakup will help with the char. Char not burn.
- While meat is cooking, add the diced tomato and sauce into a large pot and set to simmer. Add Italian seasoning, Worstershire, beef broth, and sugar.
- Once the meat is sufficiently browned add onions back in as well as the garlic. Cook for an additional 90 seconds.
- Add meat, onion, and garlic mixture to sauce and stir thouroughly.
- Bring all to a low boil and lower heat to a low simmer.
- Keep simmering until the paste is a nice brown color.
- Add browned paste to sauce and simmer as long as you want.
- Add citrus. Add a bit of red wine or beer and let the alcohol cook off before getting too picky about flavor – about 10 minutes.
- Don’t be shy with the pepper but do not over salt. Now is the time to tweak your flavorings with chile flakes and whatever else you think might be good.
- Cook pasta according to instructions. Save a bit of the pasta water and stir a quarter cup into the sauce. Add more if the sauce seems too thick.
- Serve with garlic toast and a salad.